The end of the rainbow - Global FlyFisher

GFF logo




    
Article
Pictures

The end of the rainbow

In Denmark fishing for escaped sea farm rainbows is a welcome activity in more than one way. The sport is good and you help removing the fish from a nature where they do not belong.

By Martin Joergensen

  
+
Asger - Friend Asger with a rainbow in the 3 kilo or 6 lbs. range. This fish was extraordinarily fat as you can see from the picture.
Asger
 
We do not have extensive sea farms in Denmark, but we do have a few. Compared to Norway and its huge salmon industry, our meagre cages with rainbows are like Old McDonald's cozy farms compared to modern, large scale, industrial farms.
But still we do have them, and still a cage occasionally does break open and thousands of fish escape. And when that happens it is time to grab the rod and hit the coast!

Unwelcome
The rainbows may be a fun encounter for the fisherman, but regarded as an addition to the fauna of the Baltic Sea, these originally North American fish, are not welcome.
The rainbow is generally not considered to be able to spawn successfully in the Danish streams, but these feisty fish are able to survive well in both salt and fresh water.
And in doing so they occupy precious space from our wild fish, mainly the brown and sea trout and the salmon and mainly in the streams that are few and small in many parts of the country. There is no doubt in my mind that the many large rainbows will compete for space and food and probably also consume eggs from the wild fish during their spawning.
Whether the rainbows spawn or not is not well documented, but if they do, it is with the added risk that they will dig up eggs laid by wild fish earlier in the spawning season.


Not natural
The rainbows are unnatural in many respects. Being a non-indigenous species it has no real place in the eco system other than the one already taken by mainly sea trout, which are mostly wild fish.
Also these fish are behavioural retards, so to speak. They are hatched in tanks, smoltified in the same place and have grown large in big, floating cages where thousands of fish swim in great schools in a very confined space in mid water. There is no bottom (except for the net), no natural obstacles and first and foremost no naatural food items.
The fish are fed with pellets which are sprayed over the surface every day, and these fish are so tuned in on feeding on these sinking lumps, that they seem to have no affinity towards moving prey - or flies - during their first period in the free. A wise fly tier once devised the pellet fly, and that would probably work well on these fish.

Escapees
When these fish escape it can have many reasons. The cages sometimes just leak and a few fish can sneak out. No big deal. I imagine that many of these singles will just stick to the cages and live a monotonous life just on the other side of the net wall.
But sometimes whole cages break open allowing tonnes of fish numbering thousands to escape. In such cases the fish seem to roam in large schools, and they will eventually get to the shore, which is never far away in the enclosed seas of Denmark. This often happens during the autumn when the sea is rough and the wind can reach high speeds.
The fish are usually big - about 2-3 kilos (4-6 lbs) and well into the 50-60 centimetre or 20-25 inch range. That can be compared to the average 2-3 lbs sea trout that are common on the Danish coast. The rainbows are also fat due to the rich food source in the sea farms.


Tailless
Was it not for their scars and lack of tails, they would actually be beautiful fish. But just after the escape they are usually still marred by a totally bitten down tail - often none at all - and scars from fights and encounters with each others, the net walls and the cage.
Their looks will improve greatly during an autumn and a winter, and when caught in the spring or summer they are amongst the most beautiful fish in our waters, often rightfully referred to as steelhead.

+
Weighing - Friend Uffe watches while friend Henning weighs a fish. This one was just under 2 kilos or 4 lbs. And yes, this fishing is purely catch & kill as described in the article.
Weighing
 		 
+
Weighty fish - As you can judge from this picture, we are not talking skinny fish when we are talking escaped fish farm fish.
Weighty fish
 		 
+
Complaints, anyone? - Who can really complain here?A sunny September day, dressed in T-shirt, a 2 kilo or 4 lbs. rainbow taking you almost into the backing on a 5 weight...Beats the office any day!
Complaints, anyone?
 		 
 
How to catch an escapee
The escaped fish are confused at first. they do not seem too bright and do not appear to really eat. The usual hunting behaviour we see in sea trout is not there, and the fish will swim about in large schools not doing anything obvious.

They will reveal themselves in the shallow water, and can often be targeted with precise casts. But opposite the sea trout, they will not turn and attack a fly immediately.
Many times they will shun away, and seem more frightened than attracted. Other fish will show interest but follow the fly and not take it. Others again will nibble on the fly, and be reluctant to swallow it while a last small fraction will act much like sea trouts: god for the fly upon seeing it, strike and immediately turn.

The longer the fish stay in the free the more their behaviour will come to be like a wild fish'

Small flies seem to work well, and we have had particularly good luck with orange ones. Basically some orange dubbing on a size 8 hook will do the trick.
A bit of weight will not hurt and you can vary the color in the orange, cream and brown spectre. The fly is very efficient for sea trout too, should one pass by.

The beast must die!
Beautiful or not, these fish are killed upon landing. As already mentioned they are not natural in the Danish seas and are not welcome as anything else than a fishers' game.
Even considered as such I personally still find myself in a dilemma between the advantage of being able to catch several prize size fish in the 50-60 cenimetre or 20-24" range in a day, and saving nature the burden of these fish, which no one really knows what will do to the natural sea trout.
So preventing future escapes is important, but when new outbursts of rainbows happen, I will gladly be there to catch them again.

 


Add comment  Go to article start
User comments
From: Nycflyangler · nycflyangler·at·none.com  Link
Submitted August 19th 2009

This is a problem all over. I've read that due to escapee fish, there's now an Alantic Salmon population that runs in rivers on the west coast of North and South America.

North Pacific Chinook salmon have started to establish themselves on both coasts of South America due to escapees as well.



Want to comment this page? Fill out the form below.
Comment
Only comments
in English
are accepted!

Comentarios en Ingles
solamente, por favor!
Your name Your email
Anonymize my information. Name and email will not be shown with comment.
Notify me on new comments to this article on the above email-address.
You don't have to comment to start or stop notifications.

All comments will be screened by the GFF staff before publication.
No HTML, images, ads or links, please - we do not publish such comments...
And only English language comments will be published.
Name and email is optional but recommended.
The email will be shown in a disguised form in the final comment to protect you against spam
You can see other public comments on this page

 
More stuff to look at on The Global FlyFisher
These other stories related to "Rainbow Trout" might also interest you:

Hello Austria!

Europe: Austria is much more than skiing and climbing The Alps. The fishing in the clear streams and beautiful mountain lakes is far better than Martin Joergensen expected. Read about his fantastic trip, the clear, fast water, beautiful strong rainbows and delicate seiblings. Go to the story

More about Rainbow Trout
A few random articles for your entertainment

Vltava-Dobrá

Kasper Mühlbach - GFF's eternal grayling hunter - takes on another challenge from the Lady of the Stream. This time he travels to the Czech Republic to learn from former Czech National Fly Fishing Team member Jan Siman. Does the Eastern European grayling differ from the Swedish one?

December 9th 2005

Kola autumn - Horses, bears and fly-fishing

After a famly vacation to Turkey, Lithuanian Mindaugas Banelis decided it was high time to go fishing somewhere in the North. The target was salmon. He decided that the Kola Peninsula was the ideal place to travel to. So he set off.

February 25th 2009

Fishy art: Yoshikazu Fujioka

Ever since GFF partner Martin Joergensen first discovered Yoshikazu Fujioka's Japanese web site, which was amongst the first fishing related pages he ever found on the web, he was fascinated with Fujioka's art. Now GFF can present images from "Trouts and Seasons of the Mountain Streams".

August 10th 2007

New Streamers

Converting a classic salmon fly to hairwing form has been done for many years among salmon anglers. Recently, the gang on the streamers@ mailing list tried their hand at converting classic salmon patterns to trout flies.

April 22nd 2005