Foam Caterpillars

Published May 13th 2014

Caterpillars aren't the most common type of fishing flies, but like a good ant or beetle pattern they can be killers by an overgrown stream bank on a warm summers day.


Hard to exaggerate

I was inspired to write this after seeing these great flies on Facebook where they were tied beautifully by Spanish fly-tyer Joaquín L. Quintás. Using few and simple materials, a simple technique and great colors he produced some excellent caterpillar imitations.

Caterpillars aren't the most common flies to fish, but in stream stretches through forests and on overgrown banks they can be just as useful as a good ant or beetle pattern. We have featured the green inchworm here, tied by Argentinean Pedro Alfredo Miles, but the caterpillar is slightly larger and first and foremost characterized by its hairy appearance imitated with a dry fly hackle and giving the foam fly a very realistic look.
Apart from the foam, the keys to getting the caterpillar right are colored markers, good dry fly hackle and the right - but very-easy-to-master - tying technique.

Quintás uses cylindrical foam for his caterpillars while Miles simply uses a strip cut from a foam plate for his inchworm.
I had no cylindrical foam at first, but loads of foam sheets, so I started out with a generic caterpillar pattern using the easier-to-find sheets. If you cut a narrow strip and tie it down with tight turns, it becomes almost cylindrical. The body becomes skinny compared to a natural, but useable.
You tie in the hackle in the rear. If you use a foam strip rather than a cylinder, you tie in the foam strip pointing backwards and fold it forwards, tie it down to form the first segment, lift and take the thread a bit forward, tie another segment, lift and so on.


The natural larva have dozens of really narrow segments, which can be difficult to imitate precisely, but less can do. I typically get about 8-10 segments on a size 4 hook, and I'm sure it looks segmented enough for the fish to be fooled.
It's easier to get narrow segments when the foam is a cylinder, which is simply ribbed with the tying thread in close turns.
If you use cylindrical foam, cut a slit in it and press it over the hook shank and wrap over it in semi-tight turns to compress it and form segments. You can add a bit of glue to the shank first to secure the foam better than the loose tying thread does.

I'm sure it looks segmented enough for the fish to be fooled

Cut or melt the foam to form a head. Many caterpillars have pronounced black heads, typically smaller diameter than the body. You can consider either switching to a black thread or using a black marker to dye the thread before the final wraps or simply mark the foam itself when the fly is done.
You can use markers to give the foam different accents, spots or stripes. Many caterpillars are very colorful and have beautiful contrasting patterns, and you are almost free to play as you please, because it's almost impossible to outdo nature when it comes to patterns and colors. You can of course look at the most common caterpillars in your area and take your cue from there.
Wrap the hackle forward in the grooves in the foam and tie it down, trim and whip finish and you have a nice caterpillar. Again you need not be modest. Many natural caterpillars are very hairy, and an ordinary dry fly hackle wrapped 6-8 times will not be an exaggeration.


Foam Caterpillar

HookCurved emerger hook size 2-8
Tying threadBlack 8/0
BodyFoam cylinder, colors like tan, brown, green, olive
DotsMatching color(s) (waterproof marker)
HackleDry fly saddle hackle, grizzly, brown, dun
HeadBlack (waterproof marker)

Tying instructions
  1. Start the thread in the rear of the hook
  2. Tie in the hackle
  3. Cut a shallow slit in the foam cylinder
  4. Add superglue to the hook shank (optional)
  5. Pass the slit over the hook shank
  6. Pass the thread over the foam and tie down
  7. Wrap the thread forwards in tight open turns, creating clear segmentation in the foam
  8. Add colored dots in a regular pattern to the segments using markers
  9. Wrap the hackle in the grooves formed by the thread
  10. Tie down hackle and foam and whip finish under the foam
  11. Cut surplus thread, foam and hackle
  12. Varnish
  13. Mark the head black

The naturals float like corks thanks to the hairs, and these flies are similarly high floating. They are fished on a floating line with the fly is best tied to the tippet using a loop knot, allowing the fly to move and wiggle a bit, indicating some struggle in the surface. Cast it close to the bank, preferably under branches sticking out over the water, maybe cutting under the branches using a very flat cast with the line arcs horizontal and close to the surface. You can simply dead drift the fly, but a twitch induced into the fly line by tapping the rod just above the handle, can give some sudden but small jerks in the fly, which enhances the impression of an animal fighting the water. Wiggling the rod tip can also induce some motion in the fly, which is of course pretty lifeless as it is.

Colorful caterpillars

User comments
GFF staff comment
From: Martin Joergensen · martin·at·  Link
Submitted April 10th 2015


Rainy's is your friend when it comes to foam. They have it all... and more.


From: Skip · skipr·at·  Link
Submitted April 9th 2015

I love this fly, Great job. Does anyone have a source for the small foam cylinders in various colors? I can't seem to find them. Thank you

From: Hugo He · hugohekan·at·  Link
Submitted November 7th 2014

Great work. Thanks for the sharing.

Want to comment this page? Fill out the form below.
Only comments
in English
are accepted!

Comentarios en Ingles
solamente, por favor!

Your name Your email
Anonymize my information. Name and email will not be shown with comment.
Notify me on new comments to this article on the above email-address.
You don't have to comment to start or stop notifications.

All comments will be screened by the GFF staff before publication.
No HTML, images, ads or links, please - we do not publish such comments...
And only English language comments will be published.
Name and email is optional but recommended.
The email will be shown in a disguised form in the final comment to protect you against spam
You can see other public comments on this page