The Global FlyFisher - The Largest and Best Place to go for Online Fly Fishing and Fly Tying
Book, video and gear reviews
First published June 26th 1995 - More than 19 years ago
How to dress salmon flies
Reviewed by Martin Joergensen
Mon, 26 Jun 1995 01:59:17 +0100 (MET)
Fly tyers and book lovers,
As promised not so long ago, I hereby submit the review of a 'classic' in the true meaning of the word. A book originally published in 1914, but later reprinted several times. Put to my disposition by a generous listmember. Thanks for bringing this book to my attention...
First published 1914, Published by Adam and Charles Black, London 1977
Price: Present price unknown, but I've seen it recently in Denmark and
it should still be available.
Have I gone completely out of my mind?
No, of course not. One of the great things about tying flies is the diversity of patterns and methods, and I'll stick my head out and say that any fly tyer can learn from studying almost any kind of tying. My own tying -- mostly very simple and rather large streamer types of flies -- has improved drastically by studying intricate, small dry fly patterns and the technique used for them. I've also read about salmon flies before, and even though I'm not very good at neither dries nor salmon flies, I still believe that knowing what I know about these flies add to my ability as a tyer specialized in my particular kind of flies.
And there's always something to learn, even from -- or should I say especially from -- a book from 1914.
Like Striper Moon this is a very quotable book. I like short, concentrated books, that don't waste too much time on repetitions and smalltalk. Mr. Pryce-Tannatt is a writer just after my heart, when it comes to that. He does not beat around the bush and talk in length about things that don't concern the subject. On the contrary he aims directly for the essence, and accounts for it in a way that often makes it necessarry to read every line twice or more to get all the information packed in there.
His english is nothing less than beautiful. Not only because it belongs to an era where language was different, but because each sentence has a rythm and a structure that makes it a natural whole. It's a pleasure to read a book as this and I often caught myself giggeling with joy over the beauty and precision in a paragraph. This is one of the great blessings of this book.
Pryce-Tannats view of the tying is not so different from that found in many modern books. It seems quite up to date, which is hardly surprising when the type of flies are taken into consideration. The principles behind classic salmon flies have indeed changed very little -- if at all -- since 1914. Therfore any fly tyer will be very well educated on names, proportions and proper choice of materials after having read the first couple of chapters in P-T's book.
Not before hooks and tools are mentioned does one really feel the age of
this book. P-T ties on blind hooks only (no eyes) and argues against the
use of eyed hooks in this way:
"...apart from the fact that they [the eyes] crack off very readily in windy weather, it is not easy to specify their disadvantages in many words."He does so in length anyway and concludes among other things:
"Perhaps the greatest enemy to the eyed hook is the badly designed and badly made eye which figures on quite 99 per cent of all eyed salmon fly hooks"The gut loop is P-T's way of eying a hook, and this of course makes his flies look even more 'classic'. He does choose the gut from practical reasons also -- not only aestethic ones.
In his chapter on tools he says what many have said after him on scissors
and pliers. He uses a very small selection of good tools, but completely
missing among these is the vice. P-T recommends tying without a vice,
because, as he says:
"Professional tyers usually dispense entirly with it on the grounds that they have far more complete command of the fly in all its stages, and can see better what they are doing when they rely upon their fingers alone".So there! OK, he does tie big flies (up to several inches), but still I consider using the hands exclusively an impressive task -- especially when taking into consideration that bobbins and bobbin holders are completely unknown and tying is done with short strands of silk while holding this thread and materials 'in catch' and 'in hold' with the hand that holds the hook as he describes it.
P-T goes through a series of patterns, from the wingless grub to the winged patterns and spey flies. Each pattern adds a new set of methods and in each description he does not repeat identical processes but refers to methods already described. This makes the descriptions very compact, and even though it's more demanding to read, it puts the reader in a position where full undersatnding of the previous chapter is required before you go on. This makes the book an ideal but also quite demanding teacher.
Of course you could argue that descriptions of how to tie old flies using old materials and methods -- and no vice -- are not very usefull nowadays. But not so. P-T does get very good points across in every chapter, and gives sound advise that can be used by every tyer. You can be mused by some of the methods, but still they make good sense.
The book is filled with drawings. These are -- like the tying methods --
based upon holding the hook in the hands, but still give a lot of tips
on preparing and handling materials, just like the text.
The second best part of the book (the best is still the language) is the 'tables' in the back. These tables are color photos of flies described and referred to in the text. I lasted a while before I realised why I loved these photos so much. Normally I find salmon flies a bit 'too much'. They are too colorfull, often disharmonic, impractical exebition pieces which are not necessarily tied with fishing in mind. I've rarely seen the 'classic' patterns tied true to the original, except for framing and selling at high prices. Any other classic salmon fly is liable to be very much unlike the original. For fishing, they don't tie them like they used to.
Looking at these flies, I realized that I was looking at fishing flies... 'real' flies. Most of these flies are compact with low wings indicating a fly that will endure fishing. Also they are much less colorfull than most of the fancy salmon flies I've seen in other books. I'm a natural color fan ('earthy' as someone has put it) and it was a relief to see salmon flies that were kept mainly in brown, tan, and subdued yellow and orange hues. These flies look effective, and still very beautiful. They are not tied by P-T himself (***), but added later on in a reprint and tied by the Welsh tyer Terry Griffiths whos style seems much like P-T's own.
As John Vinyard remarks in his closing chapter added to the book in the 70's P-T's flies represent 'craft' and not 'art' -- and that's the way it should be (says I, not Vinyard)
This is a book that I would not recommend to the beginner. Even if you
want to tie salmon flies I'd say you'd be better off with many other
books. But when your tying skills have reached a certain level, it's
time to look around for books that can widen your horizon.
(***) I was later informed that this is not true. The flies are actually tied by P-T himself. Sorry...