Ultimate Caddis ?

The forums are very quiet

The Global FlyFisher forum has existed for almost as long as the site, and the oldest posts are more than 20 years old. Forums aren't what they used to be. Social media has taken over a lot of their roles, and the GFF form is very quiet ... to put it mildly.
We keep everything online for the sake of history, and preserve the posts for as long as possible, but as you will see, quite a few of them aren't in a good shape, but rely on old images hosted elsewhere, which are no longer available, odd codes from old systems and much more, which can't be shown in a decent way.
But the posts are here, and you can - if you insist - start new threads. But don't stay awake waiting for replies, because they are unfortunately few and far apart.
Martin

Patterns

Ruan's Killer Caddis,
I am hesitant to say that I invented this fly....but I actually think I did, It all started some time ago when I was fishing in the river Ipoyl in northern Hungary , there was quite a Caddis hatch , so I opted for an CDC &EHC - a great floater , but not unsinkable , especially with hundreds of bleak around ( for those of you who don't know bleak.... they are small fish +- 10cm on average whose sole purpose on earth is to sink well presented dries) , so after my EHC was sunk by a bleak I thought to myself, it has to be possible to make an unsinkable Caddis imitation - which still looks like the natural...... after a while of experimenting I finally settled for the following recipe :

Hook : 16 - 10 TMC 100
Thread: white 8/0
Body : Cream Anton dubbing
Legs : generic hackle ( i use grizzle)
Wing : 1mm craft foam , colour - Tan
Antennae : Elk hair / stripped hackle barbs

I now have a Caddis imitation which floats like a cork , looks realistic , skates across the water very well and it is very easy to tie.... what more do you need ? I now use this fly almost exclusively when fishing dries

[img:5a803325da]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis7.JPG[/img:5a80332…]

But as they say, the proof of the pudding is in the eating...... here is a chub which fell for a Killer caddis
[img:5a803325da]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/caddis%20catch.jpg[/img:5a803325da]

[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis1.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Debarb the hook, and lay a thread foundation
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis2.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Make a thin body with antron dubbing
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis3.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Now tie the hackle feather about 1/3 from the front of the shank
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis4.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Spin the hackle, 2 turns should be enough , tie off and cut the remainder of the hackle
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis5.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Now cut out a triangular piece of 1mm craft foam , the size will be dictated by the hook you are using , but the foam should never extend past the bend of the hook - this will lead to fewer hook ups
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis6.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
The foam needs to be secured in two places, once where the hackle finishes, and again behind the eye of the hook,this avoids the foam staying flat which makes the fly twist during casting.
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis7.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
You can now tie in the antennae , this is an optional extra - the fly works just as well without it...
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis8.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Thats it.....easy or what ? this is the bottom view, looks like a caddis to me..give it a try and tight lines & screaming reels !

Nice fly but I'm not sure that fish takes that as caddis but something else, or well you don't never know surely ;) But foam wing is too wide in my opinion to imitate caddis on the water surface. Check out for example some pictures from the web how the caddis looks like on the water surface, in my opinion narrow winged patterns imitate better caddis on the water suface on drift :)

One really good caddis imitation is made from deer hair like Coddard caddis but with parachute hackle and no other body than deer hair, that's great caddis pattern and floats well too.

I have noticed that using narrow wing pattern is better than wider.

Something like that on the image, body can still be however more narrow than in the image (hook size in the image is #14 and #16).

[img:16343803d0]http://www.perhokalastajat.net/kuvagalleria/albums/userpics/caddiksia.j…]

Hi Masi ,

Thanks , The wing can be folded or trimmed to give a different profile.

I know, and like the Goddards caddis , but after a while the deer hair gets soaked which causes the fly to sink - something which does not happen to foam , plus the killer caddis is much easier to tie....... I am a bit challenged by deer hair.... especially on small hooks.

Yes, foam can be cutted to give more narrow profile but less you have the foam more easily fly will sink :( I have tried foam winged patterns and not been wery happy for those, but maybe i will try it again some day ;)

I use fly floatant with my Coddard variation, it floats quite well but of course you have to false casts it to get it dry some times.

By the way I know the problem with small fish that takes dry flies, there's a lot of small fish also in streams and rivers in Finland too ;)

Tight lines!

By the way, here's one 45cm grayling with that kind of Coddard caddis variation, hook size #14:

[img:f83ad57ab3]http://www.globalflyfisher.com/pix/20070725/b1812ca6fb9.jpg[/img:f83ad5…]

hey Masi, you tie it the way you want! Your version looks good enough for me and I will give it a go here in Scotland this summer. Tight lines.

Anybody use a peacock caddis? I tie mine onto a curved nymph hook. The elk wing and hackle keep the top half on the surface at an angle and the peacock body sits curved down into the water like a caddis that's emerging, except it bridge even that fine gap between emerger and adult.

The attached photo shows my variation, but on this one I tied the wing too far back. Normally, I tie it much close to the front with just a few turns of hackle.

Jared DuBach -- Angle Lake Fly Tyers
http://angellakeflytyers.ecrater.com

@waterdog

Thank you very much for [color=blue:2e589ba14a]Step by step sharing[/color:2e589ba14a] with us !

Feridun

Nice fly Waterdog, I will tie some up and give them a go, they should be deadly scated across the Major Jones pool in the evening.
Thanks for posting the pattern.
All the best.
Mike.

[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis1.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Debarb the hook, and lay a thread foundation
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis2.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Make a thin body with antron dubbing
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis3.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Now tie the hackle feather about 1/3 from the front of the shank
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis4.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Spin the hackle, 2 turns should be enough , tie off and cut the remainder of the hackle
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis5.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Now cut out a triangular piece of 1mm craft foam , the size will be dictated by the hook you are using , but the foam should never extend past the bend of the hook - this will lead to fewer hook ups
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis6.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
The foam needs to be secured in two places, once where the hackle finishes, and again behind the eye of the hook,this avoids the foam staying flat which makes the fly twist during casting.
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis7.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
You can now tie in the antennae , this is an optional extra - the fly works just as well without it...
[img:2b76d7c995]http://www.freeweb.hu/flyfish-hungary/Killer%20Caddis8.JPG[/img:2b76d7c…]
Thats it.....easy or what ? this is the bottom view, looks like a caddis to me..give it a try and tight lines & screaming reels !

Nice fly but I'm not sure that fish takes that as caddis but something else, or well you don't never know surely ;) But foam wing is too wide in my opinion to imitate caddis on the water surface. Check out for example some pictures from the web how the caddis looks like on the water surface, in my opinion narrow winged patterns imitate better caddis on the water suface on drift :)

One really good caddis imitation is made from deer hair like Coddard caddis but with parachute hackle and no other body than deer hair, that's great caddis pattern and floats well too.

I have noticed that using narrow wing pattern is better than wider.

Something like that on the image, body can still be however more narrow than in the image (hook size in the image is #14 and #16).

[img:16343803d0]http://www.perhokalastajat.net/kuvagalleria/albums/userpics/caddiksia.j…]

Hi Masi ,

Thanks , The wing can be folded or trimmed to give a different profile.

I know, and like the Goddards caddis , but after a while the deer hair gets soaked which causes the fly to sink - something which does not happen to foam , plus the killer caddis is much easier to tie....... I am a bit challenged by deer hair.... especially on small hooks.

Yes, foam can be cutted to give more narrow profile but less you have the foam more easily fly will sink :( I have tried foam winged patterns and not been wery happy for those, but maybe i will try it again some day ;)

I use fly floatant with my Coddard variation, it floats quite well but of course you have to false casts it to get it dry some times.

By the way I know the problem with small fish that takes dry flies, there's a lot of small fish also in streams and rivers in Finland too ;)

Tight lines!

By the way, here's one 45cm grayling with that kind of Coddard caddis variation, hook size #14:

[img:f83ad57ab3]http://www.globalflyfisher.com/pix/20070725/b1812ca6fb9.jpg[/img:f83ad5…]

hey Masi, you tie it the way you want! Your version looks good enough for me and I will give it a go here in Scotland this summer. Tight lines.

Anybody use a peacock caddis? I tie mine onto a curved nymph hook. The elk wing and hackle keep the top half on the surface at an angle and the peacock body sits curved down into the water like a caddis that's emerging, except it bridge even that fine gap between emerger and adult.

The attached photo shows my variation, but on this one I tied the wing too far back. Normally, I tie it much close to the front with just a few turns of hackle.

Jared DuBach -- Angle Lake Fly Tyers
http://angellakeflytyers.ecrater.com

@waterdog

Thank you very much for [color=blue:2e589ba14a]Step by step sharing[/color:2e589ba14a] with us !

Feridun

Nice fly Waterdog, I will tie some up and give them a go, they should be deadly scated across the Major Jones pool in the evening.
Thanks for posting the pattern.
All the best.
Mike.

Since you got this far …


The GFF money box

… I have a small favor to ask.

Long story short

Support the Global FlyFisher through several different channels, including PayPal.

Long story longer

The Global FlyFisher has been online since the mid-90's and has been free to access for everybody since day one – and will stay free for as long as I run it.
But that doesn't mean that it's free to run.
It costs money to drive a large site like this.
See more details about what you can do to help in this blog post.

The Global FlyFisher was updated to a new publishing system early March 2025, and there may still be a few glitches while the last bits get fixed. If you meet anything that doesn't work, please let me know.
Martin - martin@globalflyfisher.com